Gutters are an essential part of your home’s exterior, as they help to protect your roof, walls, foundation, and landscaping from water damage. Gutters collect and divert rainwater and snowmelt away from your home, preventing leaks, mold, rot, erosion, and flooding. However, gutters are also exposed to various elements and hazards, such as weather, debris, animals, and accidents, that can cause them to wear out, crack, sag, or detach over time. When this happens, you may wonder whether you should repair or replace your gutters.

The answer depends on several factors, such as the extent and type of damage, the age and material of your gutters, the cost and availability of repairs, and the condition and value of your home. In some cases, you may be able to fix minor issues with some DIY tools and materials, or hire a professional gutter contractor to do the job. In other cases, you may need to replace your entire gutter system with a new one that is more durable, efficient, and attractive.

In this article, we will help you decide when to replace your gutters instead of repairing them by providing some guidelines and tips. We will also share some resources on how to choose the best gutter system for your home and how to install or replace gutters properly.

Signs That You Need To Replace Your Gutters

The first step to deciding whether to repair or replace your gutters is to inspect them regularly and look for signs of damage or deterioration. Some of the common signs that indicate that you need to replace your gutters are:

1. Cracks, holes, or rust: 

Cracks, holes, or rust spots on your gutters can cause water to leak out of them and damage your home’s exterior or interior. While small cracks or holes can be patched up with some sealant or caulk, large ones may require replacing the affected sections or the whole gutter system. Rust is also a sign of corrosion that can weaken your gutters and make them prone to breaking or collapsing. If you see multiple or widespread cracks, holes, or rust on your gutters, it may be time to replace them.

2. Sagging or pulling away: 

Sagging or pulling away your gutters from your roof or fascia board can affect their functionality and appearance. Sagging or pulling away can be caused by various factors, such as heavy snow or ice accumulation, clogged debris, improper installation, or damaged hangers or fasteners. While sagging or pulling away can sometimes be fixed by adjusting or replacing the hangers or fasteners, it can also indicate structural damage to your roof or fascia board that may require replacing the entire gutter system.

3. Peeling paint or rotting wood: 

Peeling paint or rotting wood on your home’s exterior near your gutters can be a sign of water damage caused by faulty gutters. Water can seep behind your gutters and cause moisture problems that can affect your paint, siding, or wood. 

Peeling paint or rotting wood can also attract pests or mold that can further damage your home.

If you notice peeling paint or rotting wood on a large area of your home’s exterior, you may need to replace your gutters as well as repair the affected surfaces. 

4. Eroding landscaping: 

Eroding landscaping around your home can be a sign of poor drainage caused by faulty gutters. Gutters that are clogged, leaking, or misaligned can cause water to overflow or spill over the sides and create puddles or ditches on the ground. This can wash away your soil, mulch, or plants, and ruin your landscaping.  It can also cause flooding or foundation problems for your home. If you notice eroding landscaping around your home, you may need to replace your gutters and improve your drainage system.

Benefits Of Replacing Your Gutters

Replacing your gutters may seem like a costly and time-consuming project, but it can also bring many benefits to your home and yourself. Some of the benefits of replacing your gutters are:

• Protecting your home: Replacing your gutters can help you protect your home from water damage that can affect its structure, appearance, and value. By installing new gutters that are properly sized, shaped, and installed, you can ensure that water is collected and diverted away from your home effectively and efficiently. This can prevent leaks, mold, rot, erosion, and flooding that can compromise your roof, walls, foundation, and landscaping.
• Enhancing your curb appeal: Replacing your gutters can help you enhance your curb appeal and make your home look more attractive and well-maintained. By choosing new gutters that match or complement your home’s style, color, and material, you can create a harmonious and appealing look for your home’s exterior.

You can also choose from various types of gutters that offer different features and benefits,

such as seamless gutters, vinyl gutters, aluminum gutters, copper gutters, or gutter guards.

• Saving money and time: Replacing your gutters can help you save money and time in the long run by avoiding frequent and costly repairs or damages. By investing in new gutters that are durable, resistant, and easy to maintain, you can reduce the risk of gutter problems that can require repairs or replacements in the future. You can also save time by spending less time cleaning or fixing your gutters and more time enjoying your home.

How To Choose The Best Gutter System For Your Home

If you decide to replace your gutters, you need to choose the best gutter system for your home that suits your needs, preferences, and budget. There are many factors to consider when choosing a gutter system, such as:

1. Size 

The size of your gutters refers to the width and depth of the gutter channel that determines how much water it can hold and drain. The size of your gutters should match the size of your roof and the amount of rainfall in your area. The most common sizes for residential gutters are 5 inches and 6 inches, but you may need larger or smaller sizes depending on your situation. You also need to consider the size of the downspouts, which are the vertical pipes that carry the water from the gutters to the ground. The size of the downspouts should be proportional to the size of the gutters and sufficient to handle the water flow.

2. Shape 

The shape of your gutters refers to the cross-sectional profile of the gutter channel that affects its appearance and performance. The most common shapes for residential gutters are K-style and half-round. K-style gutters have a flat bottom and back, and a curved front that resembles a letter K. They are popular because they are easy to install, hold more water, and blend well with most architectural styles. Half-round gutters have a semicircular shape that is more traditional and elegant. They are preferred because they are less prone to clogging, corrosion, or leakage, but they are also more expensive and difficult to install.

3. Material 

The material of your gutters refers to the substance that makes up the gutter channel and affects its durability, resistance, and cost. There are many types of materials for residential gutters, such as aluminum, vinyl, steel, copper, or zinc. Aluminum is the most common material because it is lightweight, rust-proof, and affordable. Vinyl is another popular material because it is easy to install, low-maintenance, and inexpensive. However, both aluminum and vinyl can fade, crack, or dent over time. Steel is a stronger and sturdier material that can withstand harsh weather conditions, but it is also heavier, harder to install, and prone to rusting. Copper is a premium material that offers a beautiful and distinctive look, but it is also very expensive and requires professional installation. Zinc is a similar material to copper that develops a patina over time, but it is also costly and complex to install.

4. Features 

The features of your gutters refer to the additional components or accessories that enhance the functionality or appearance of your gutter system. There are many types of features for residential gutters, such as seamless gutters, gutter guards, or decorative hangers.

• Seamless gutters: Seamless gutters are gutters that are custom-made to fit your home’s dimensions and have no joints or seams along their length. They are preferred because they reduce the risk of leaks, clogs, or sagging that can occur at the seams. However, they are also more expensive and require professional installation. 

• Gutter guards: Gutter guards are devices that cover or fit into your gutters to prevent leaves, twigs, or other debris from entering them. They are useful because they make your gutters easier to clean and maintain. However, they are also an added expense and may not work well with some types of gutters or debris.

• Decorative hangers: Decorative hangers are brackets that support your gutters and add some style or charm to your home’s exterior. They come in various shapes, sizes, and designs, such as spikes, ferrules, hidden hangers, or ornamental hangers.

How To Install Or Replace Gutters Properly

If you choose to install or replace your gutters yourself, you need to follow some steps and precautions to do it properly and safely. Here are some general steps on how to install or replace gutters:

Step 1: Measure and mark the gutter length and slope. You need to measure the length of your roof edge where you want to install or replace your gutters and mark the starting and ending points. You also need to mark the slope or pitch of your gutters, which is the angle at which they will drain the water. The recommended slope is 1/4 inch per 10 feet of gutter, which means that for every 10 feet of gutter, the endpoint should be 1/4 inch lower than the starting point. You can use a chalk line or a level to mark the slope on your fascia board.

Step 2: Cut and join the gutter sections. You need to cut the gutter sections according to your measurements, using a hacksaw or a tin snips. You also need to join the gutter sections together, using either slip joints or connectors. Slip joints are metal pieces that fit over the ends of two gutter sections and are secured with screws or rivets. Connectors are metal pieces that fit inside the ends of two gutter sections and are sealed with caulk or silicone. You can use either method depending on your preference and gutter type.

Step 3: Attach the gutter hangers. You need to attach the gutter hangers to your fascia board, using screws or nails. Gutter hangers are brackets that support your gutters and keep them in place. You can choose from various types of gutter hangers, such as spikes, ferrules, hidden hangers, or decorative hangers. You should space the hangers about 2 feet apart along your fascia board, and make sure they are aligned with your slope marks.

Step 4: Install the gutter sections. You need to install the gutter sections onto the hangers, starting from one end of your roof edge and working your way to the other end. You should snap or slide the gutter sections into the hangers, and make sure they are secure and level. You should also overlap the gutter sections by about 4 inches at each joint, and seal them with caulk or silicone.

Step 5: Install the downspouts. You need to install the downspouts at each end or corner of your gutter system, using elbows, brackets, and screws. Downspouts are vertical pipes that carry the water from your gutters to the ground or a drainage system. You should cut the downspouts according to your measurements, and attach them to your gutters with elbows. You should also attach brackets to your wall or siding, and secure the downspouts with screws. You should make sure that the downspouts are straight and flush with your wall or siding.

Step 6: Test and adjust your gutter system. You need to test and adjust your gutter system to make sure it works properly and efficiently. You can use a hose or a bucket to pour water into your gutters and check for any leaks, clogs, or sagging. You can also observe how the water flows and drains from your gutters and downspouts, and make sure there are no puddles or ditches on the ground. You can fix any issues by tightening or replacing screws, sealing or patching holes, cleaning or unclogging debris, or adjusting or replacing hangers.

Conclusion

Installing or replacing gutters is an important project that can improve your home’s protection, appearance, and value. However, it can also be a challenging and costly project that requires careful planning and execution. By following the guidelines and tips that we shared in this article, you can decide when to replace your gutters instead of repairing them, choose the best gutter system for your home, and install or replace gutters properly and safely. You can also use the resources that we referenced in this article to learn more about gutters and how to maintain them. We hope that this article has been helpful and informative for you and that you enjoy your new gutters.

FAQ